' Peabody thoroughly embodies Beth’s gentle soul; her performance is an immense pleasure. '

- Broadway World review of Little Women

' Katie Peabody... adds a quiet intensity. '

- Broadway World review of Lear's Shadow

' Katie Peabody... embodying the beautiful Beth March, shining warmly across the stage like the character in her own home. '

- DramaInTheHood Review of Little Women

' Katie Peabody gives a stunning performance that begins with the giddy ebullience of a curious girl on the brink of life and abruptly shifts to quiet anguish. '

- Haunting review of In Another Room

' Peabody gives a solid performance, with their desperation dominating [their] final moments. '

- Film Threat review of Anniversary

' Peabody turns in a sweet performance. '

- Broadway World review of Little Women

' Katie Peabody is sweet and heartbreaking... she brings authenticity and pure emotion... '

- South Pasadena Review of Lear's Shadow

' While I admire Jo's courage, I have to confess my heart belongs to Beth (Peabody). But I believe Jo's does, too. Every writer needs a loving person who says, "Tell me a story." '

- Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Review of Little Women

' Peabody’s charming performance... draws the audience into the teenager’s harrowing story of survival on Matinicus Rock.

Peabody perfectly captures the adolescent Abbie. She is almost constantly in motion with teenage angst and energy. The actor relentlessly reels the audience into Abbie’s world as her family’s tranquility and safety is upended. By the time the storm arrives, every theatergoer is emotionally gripped on Matinicus Rock with her.

It is one of the most mesmerizing performances under the tenure of Artistic Director Jonathan Berry. '

- Bangor Daily News Review of Matinicus